How to Paint Shutters Like a Pro (Even If You’ve Never Done It Before)

If your shutters are looking faded, chalky, or just plain dated, painting them is one of the fastest and most cost-effective ways to give your home’s exterior a facelift. But can shutters be painted? And what’s the best paint for vinyl shutters or plastic shutters? Let’s break it all down. 

Can You Paint Shutters – The Quick Answer 

Yes, you can paint vinyl, plastic, and even wood shutters. In fact, painting shutters is a great DIY project that can deliver professional-looking results if you follow the right steps. 

What Kind of Paint Should You Use on Shutters? 

The type of paint you need depends on the material: 

• Vinyl shutters: Use an exterior latex paint formulated for plastics. Look for labels that mention "vinyl safe" or “exterior paint for vinyl shutters.” 
  
  
• Plastic shutters: A high-quality spray paint for plastic shutters can offer an even finish, especially for shutters with louvers or detailed trim. 
  
  
• Wood shutters: Prime bare wood areas in oil primer. Scuff sand old oil produts, and finish in high quality acrylic paint. 

Sherwin Williams, Benjamin Moore, and Behr all offer good options that bond well to vinyl and plastic.

Should You Remove Shutters Before Painting? 

Ideally, yes. Removing shutters makes the process easier and reduces the risk of drips on your siding or windows. However, you can paint shutters without removing them. Just use painter’s tape generously and work slowly. 

How to Paint Vinyl or Plastic Shutters (Step-by-Step) 

Here’s how to do it right: 

1. Clean the Shutters Thoroughly

Use a mixture of water and mild detergent, or a dedicated cleaner like TSP. Rinse and allow to dry completely. 

2. Remove Gloss (If Needed) 

Lightly sand shutters with fine-grit sandpaper to help paint adhere. Some shutters have a glossy finish that repels paint. 

3. Prime (Optional but Recommended) 

Use a bonding primer for plastic or vinyl. This helps ensure long-lasting results. 

4. Choose Your Paint Method 

Brush or roller works well for flat-panel and louvered shutters and wood. 

5. Paint 

Apply 2–3 light coats, allowing each to dry per the product instructions. 

6. Reattach and Admire 

Let the paint cure fully (usually 24–48 hours) before reattaching to your home. 

Tips for Painting Shutters on the House 

If you're painting shutters while they’re still mounted, prep is even more important: 

• Cover surrounding siding and windows. 
  
  
• Work with a steady hand. A small angled brush gives you the most control. 
  
  
• Choose a calm day with mild weather to avoid wind-blown debris sticking to fresh paint. 

Popular Shutter Colors in Pittsburgh Homes 

Locally here in Pittsburgh, homeowners often ask us what shutter colors work best for this area? In 2025, we’re seeing a few clear favorites:

• Matte black – A strong contrast against Pittsburgh’s brick or light siding homes 
  
  
• Navy blue and forest green – Timeless picks that pair well with the city's traditional architecture 
  
  
• Warm gray or taupe – Perfect for stone exteriors and neutral color palettes common in the suburbs 

Final Thoughts – Painting Shutters is A Great Way to Refresh Your Home 

Painting exterior shutters is one of the easiest ways to boost your curb appeal. Whether you go with spray paint for vinyl shutters or brush on a bold new color, just make sure to prep properly and use the right products for your shutter material. 

If you need residential painting in the Pittsburgh area, our team at ImageWorks Painting has been providing high quality services for decades.